Saturday, November 7, 2020

Fallen from Grace

These are words found in the book of Galatians, words written by the Apostle Paul concerning those who had received the spirit by the hearing of faith (3:2-3), but were being charmed (“bewitched” NKJ) into thinking justification was not by faith alone in Christ, but required the addition of keeping certain rituals of the law, especially the rite of circumcision.  

Some may argue the issue in Galatians is not justification but practical sanctification, but it’s both, because the error being promoted is that justification is not complete by faith alone, but requires the sanctification that comes through the Law to secure justification.

Paul reminds his readers that “Abraham believed God, and it was accounted to him for righteousness” and “Therefore know that only those who are of faith are sons of Abraham.” (3.6-7)  Paul warns them that if they become circumcised, “Christ will profit you nothing” and “I testify again to every man who becomes circumcised that he is a debtor to keep the whole law…You have become estranged from Christ, you who attempt to be justified by law: you have fallen from grace.” (5.2-4)  

If they believe their salvation is not complete by faith alone, but requiring fulfilling certain requirements of the Law, then they will not have the “profit” that comes from Christ for a righteous life-walk.  The shift of confidence will result in their unprofitableness in their testimony to Christ alone for salvation, as it will put the focus and confidence in one’s flesh.

 

The words “fallen from grace” seem to get used for those who fall away in the sense that they were once believers who have become agnostics or atheists.  I believe that is not an appropriate application of these words.  That is another issue not addressed here.  These words are used with reference to those who still believe in Jesus as the Christ, but they have fallen from grace in the sense that they have departed from ‘faith alone’ for justification before God.  It's not about believers losing their salvation or never having been saved because of some supposed false faith.  It’s about believers who have been charmed by teachers into believing salvation is not by faith alone in Christ alone. 

This same kind of issue is addressed in the book of Hebrews in Chapters 6 and 10 concerning believers who are being persuaded to go back to observing the Law of Moses for salvation, though they started out by believing in Christ alone for salvation.  Hebrews 6.4-6 speaks about these believers having been “enlightened,” tasting the “heavenly gift,” being “partakers of the “Holy Spirit” (compare with Galatians 3.2-3: having received the spirit by faith), and “have tasted the good word of God and the powers of the age to come.”  Then the author of Hebrews says, and ”they fall away…[then it is impossible] to renew them unto repentance.”  If they go this route, if they “cast away” their “confidence”(10.35) in Christ, then they have devalued the death of Christ for sins (6.6; 10.29), and the affect on their conscience will be such that a future change of mind will be impossible.  

It’s not speaking here about them becoming agnostics or atheists, but a change of mind about the value of the death of Christ alone for salvation.  If they do this, then they become unprofitable for Christ and can expect divine consequences:  “Of how much worse punishment, do you suppose, will he be thought worthy who has trampled the Son of God underfoot, counted the blood of the covenant by which he was sanctified a common thing, and insulted the Spirit of grace?   For we know Him who said, "Vengeance is Mine, I will repay," says the Lord. And again, "The Lord will judge His people." (10:29-30)  To avoid this route, the author exhorts his readers to hold fast to their confession of hope without wavering, and this is helped by the assembling of believers to stir one-another up (10.23-25).  The author reminds these believers to “recall the former days in which, after you were illuminated, you endured a great struggle with sufferings:   partly while you were made a spectacle both by reproaches and tribulations, and partly while you became companions of those who were so treated;   for you had compassion on me in my chains, and joyfully accepted the plundering of your goods, knowing that you have a better and an enduring possession for yourselves in heaven.  Therefore do not cast away your confidence, which has great reward.   For you have need of endurance, so that after you have done the will of God, you may receive the promise.”  (10:32-36)

 

It was maybe more of a struggle in the time of the early church period to continue in the teaching of faith alone in Christ alone for justification before God apart from keeping the law of Moses.  To depart from that belief would result in a legalistic life that would be unfruitful for God and bring one under Divine judgment.  To depart would be to fall from Grace.  The problem today is that justification by faith alone is not proclaimed or taught from the beginning.  Some, maybe undiscerningly, include things along with what they believe to be “faith alone.”  Some don’t discern the contradiction in what they are saying, if they say we are saved by faith alone, but they include other requirements for salvation.  They may not require circumcision, which seems totally out of the picture as a requirement, but they require other things that seem necessary for salvation to take place.  Maybe its water baptism, or maybe its some degree of moral reformation.  But these things can become the confidence of one’s salvation just like circumcision was for the early church. If they put these other things as necessary for salvation, they have departed from justification by faith alone.  If one comes to this view after they have believed in Christ for salvation, then they have “fallen from grace.” 

 

Thursday, October 22, 2020

"Apostasia" (the "falling away") is not the Rapture

"Let no one deceive you by any means; for that Day [Day of the Lord] will not come unless the falling away comes first..."  2 Thessalonians 2.3

The "falling away" in this verse is the Greek word "apostasia" which could also be translated "departure."  Our English word "apostasy" comes from this word.   

The "apostasia" will precede the Day of the Lord.  The Apostle is saying to these people that that "Day" has not come because the Apostasia must come first.  The concern is that if the Day of the Lord had come, then they missed the "gathering together" to Christ, if they understood that gathering as the "rapture" and the Day of the Lord as coming after that, being the time of God's wrath upon the earth.

The apostasia has been normally understood as it is translated in most translations as a "falling away" or “rebellion” in some spiritual sense, such as from the faith or sound doctrine.   Later in the chapter, the Apostle writes: "Therefore, brethren, stand fast and hold the traditions which you were taught, whether by word or our epistle."  This statement would support the idea of a falling away, if they did not "stand fast and hold the traditions" they were taught.   A falling away could be translated "departure," if understood as a departure from the faith or sound teaching.  

A few have tried to understand this apostasia as a physical (spatial) departure and not a spiritual one.  They have tried to promote the idea that this apostasia is the rapture itself.  By doing this, they can place the Day of the Lord at an earlier time in the scheme of things.  They can also place the rapture at or before the time when they think the revealing of the "son of perdition [destruction]" takes place, which is the other thing that must occur before the Day of the Lord.

I saw a poll taken in a discussion group recently where it was asked if the apostasia is the rapture, and quite a number believed it was.  Are they taking this view because it supports their view of end time events?

The word apostasia only appears twice in the New Testament.  The other time it is used is in Acts 21:21 "but they have been informed about you that you teach all the Jews who are among the Gentiles to forsake Moses, saying that they ought not to circumcise their children nor to walk according to the customs."

The word "forsake" translates apostasia.  This is written concerning the Apostle Paul, being accused of teaching Jews among the Gentiles to forsake Moses.  This is about a departure from certain customs, just like the Thessalonians were exhorted to stand fast and hold the traditions, for a forsaking of them would be an apostasia.  It would be best to understand apostasia by how it is used elsewhere in Scripture.

The word apostasia appears in the Greek translation of the Old Testament and is used in the sense of a spiritual kind of departure.   Joshua 22.22b, 23 reads: "if we have transgressed before the Lord before by apostasy, let him not deliver us this day, and if we have built to ourselves an altar so as to apostatize from the Lord our God."  2 Chronicles 29.19: "and all the vessels which king Ahaz polluted in his reign; in his apostasy, we have prepared and purified."   Jeremiah 2.19: "Thine apostasy shall correct thee, and thy wickedness shall reprove thee and see, that thy forsaking me has been bitter to thee, saith the Lord thy God."  

Alan Kurschner, a prewrath rapturist, quotes pretribulation rapture scholar Paul Feinberg: “If one searches for the uses of the noun “apostasy” in the 355 occurrences over the 300-year period between the second century B.C. and the first century A.D., one will not find a single instance where this word refers to a physical departure.”  

Kurschner also points out, “The classical Greek Liddell and Scott lexicon lists the primary meaning of apostasia as “defection, revolt”; and “departure, disappearance” as a secondary meaning. The only example of this secondary meaning of spatial departure is found five centuries later after the New Testament. It is sloppy and simply fallacious to read back not only an obscure meaning but one that is five centuries after the New Testament!”

The uses of Apostasia in the scriptures is not for a physical departure but a defection or spiritual departure.  And there are all the occurrences between a period of 300 years of which the word is not used for a physical departure.  The overwhelming evidence is that apostasia in 2 Thessalonians 2 is a defection, a spiritual falling away. 

 A falling away is something the Scriptures warn about within the church and something the church has anticipated in the last days.  First Timothy 4.1:  “Now the Spirit expressly says that in latter times some will  depart   from  the faith, giving heed to deceiving spirits and doctrines of demons…”  Second Timothy 3.1-5:  “3:1  But know this, that in the last days perilous times will come:  2  For men will be lovers  of themselves,  lovers  of money, boasters, proud, blasphemers, disobedient to parents, unthankful, unholy,  3  unloving, unforgiving, slanderers, without self-control, brutal, despisers of good,  4  traitors, headstrong, haughty,  lovers  of pleasure rather than  lovers  of God,  5  having a form of godliness but denying its power. And from such people turn away!”

Saturday, October 17, 2020

Mark of the Beast's Eternal Consequence

There are a number of speculations about what this “Mark” may be which will be implemented during the time that most (futurists) identify as the “Great Tribulation.” 

 

Probably most futurists—those who believe that most of the book of Revelation is yet future—anticipate the Mark will be possible because of modern technology.  

 

I hear many Christians seemingly fearful that they may take the Mark unknowingly.  They seem to think they could lose their salvation if the Mark is involved with an implanted chip or something in a vaccine.   

Whatever this Mark will be, I don’t see how it could work that way.  Whatever it is, or however it works the most troubling part of it all is the consequence associated with having it. The consequences associated with it is what I find to be the most disturbing.


 "He causes all… to receive a  mark  on their right hand or on their foreheads,  and that no one may buy or sell except one who has the  mark… And the smoke of their torment ascends forever and ever; and they have no rest day or night, who worship the beast and his image, and whoever receives the  mark of his name." 

(Revelation 13.16-17; 14.11 NKJV)

 

Revelation reveals that to have the Mark seals one’s eternal fate.  I have heard that Dr. John McArthur takes the view that one can still be saved after they take the Mark. (I’ve read this by others but haven’t heard him say it.)  He has received a lot of criticism for that claim, and rightfully so, according to Revelation 14.   

Whatever one may think the Mark may be or how one thinks it works, there’s something about it that if you have it on your forehead or right hand, your eternal fate is sealed.  

 

A friend suggests the number 666 can be used by those who are wise enough (computer software programming savvy?) to generate an encryption key to decipher the code to hack /break the Beast’s system, so they can buy and sell without coming under the eternal condemnation of having the Mark—ok, fine, but why does having the Mark seal one’s fate?


I can only conclude that whatever the Mark is, and however it actually works, it must involve a state of mind or conscience that has become so hardened to the truth of God’s way of salvation, which is through faith alone in Christ as Savior from sin, that they have reached a point of no return:  those with the Mark will be those kind of people.  

I do think there will be those who will not take the Mark who are not believers in Christ, just because it doesn’t get implemented worldwide or for other various reasons.  I believe there will be many who were not believers in Christ who do not take the Mark, who will become believers in Christ after the great tribulation and after the rapture of the church, and some of these will be Jews who come to Christ in faith at His coming.  

 

I think that to take the Mark of the Beast involves a state of mind or conscience that has become so hardened to the truth of God’s way of salvation, which is through faith alone in Christ as Savior from sin, that they have reached a point of no return in their consciences: those with the Mark will be those kind of people who will suffer the consequence of eternal torment from God.  Taking the Mark will be like reaching a point of no return.




Friday, October 16, 2020

Kept from the “hour of trial”

 "Because you have kept My command to persevere, I also will keep you from the  hour   of   trial  which shall come upon the whole world, to test those who dwell on the earth.” Revelation 3:10 NKJV

 

The promise to keep this church of Philadelphia in Asia Minor from the “hour of trial” is believed by many, if not most futurists, as yet to be fulfilled with future believers in Christ, since that “hour of trial” has not yet come “upon the whole world.”  

Who is this promise for, and what is this “hour of trial” and what does “keep you from” mean?   

One’s views about end time events will influence the understanding of these things.  

If one believes the rapture is in view, and the "hour of trial" is the 70th week of Daniel, they may ignore the conditional part of the text that says: “Because you have kept my command to persevere," because what if a believer does not persevere?  This is more a problem for pretribulationists.  They must assume that all believers persevere.  Yet even those who are not pretrib rapturists, such as prewrath rapturists, and believe the hour of trial is the day of the Lord, they would have the same problem with conditional statement, because do all believers persevere?

Ithas been demonstrated by some to grammatically apply to the previous verse (verse 9) the conditional statement, and it should read: “…indeed I will make them come and worship before your feet, and to know that I have loved you, because you have kept My command to persevere.”   If one believes the “keep you from” is the rapture, then the conditional statement doesn’t become a problem as to whom the promise applies or what the promise is, in that the rapture requires one to persevere.   Of course, some may believe that believers have to persevere or they are not saved or lost their salvation.  But placing the condition on verse 9 solves that problem, whatever one's rapture view is.

I think many have just kind of ignored the implications of the condition, or they believe that if the church as a whole is in view, then they all meet this condition somehow—which could be problematic, depending on the understanding of perseverance.   I don’t have a problem with moving the conditional statement to verse 9, but I wonder if it fully removes the idea of condition from verse 10, since the promise was only stated to the Church of Philadelphia and not the other six churches addressed, and if Christ was doing something for them because of their conduct in verse 9, the promise in verse 10 could still be due to their conduct recognized in the conditional statement.  And if this “hour of trial” did not happen in their time period, and is yet future, then the application of this promise can be to a future church of similar conduct.

 

I tend to think this promise of “keep you from” is not talking about the rapture, and I tend to think the “hour of trial” is not the “Day of the Lord,” but “great tribulation” that Jesus spoke concerning in the Olivet Discourse (eg. Matthew 24.1), and Revelation 7.14 says a great multitude (of obviously saved people)  come out of it. 

If Pretribulational rapturists believe it is about the rapture of the Church (removal from the earth), they would say the “hour” is the 70th Week of Daniel (Daniel 9.27) as the Day of the Lord (the 70th Week being the last 7 years before the Second Coming of Christ being designated as “tribulation” and the Day of the Lord)—and removing the conditional statement would be a good thing, because the rapture is not just for the faithful Christians, unless you believe all Christians persevere and salvation guarantees such. 

Prewrath Rapturists may say the “hour” is the Day of the Lord, but they place it near the end of the 70th Week of Daniel and this is consistent with their view that the rapture happens at the end of great tribulation but before the Day of the Lord—removing the conditional statement would be the same issue as to all believers must persevere. 

Posttribulational Rapturists (rapture comes at end of 70th week and Great Tribulation) and some Prewrath Rapturists may see the “keep you from” as a kind of protection during the time of great tribulation and not a physical removal from the earth as in the rapture.

Though the conditional part of Revelation 3.10 may apply to verse 9, the promise of Verse 10, to be kept from the hour, is to a church of a certain approved character and conduct.  I don’t believe the rapture is conditional to the faithful only, and I don’t think salvation guarantees the faithfulness of believers.  But whether the conditional part of verse 10 belongs to verse 9 or not, it seems the promise of verse 10 is to those who have persevered.  

In Jesus’ prayer for his disciples in John 17.15, he says:  "I do not pray that You should take them out of the world, but that You should  keep  them from the  evil  one.”   This prayer  seems to be about a kind of protection.  The words “Keep” and “from” are seen used by Jesus in Revelation 3.10.  The keeping from in John 17.15 are with reference to “the evil,” the word “one” is added.  It’s similar to the part in the Lord’s prayer in Matthew 6.13: “And bring us not into temptation, but deliver us from the evil [one.]”  The prayer is for deliverance from the “evil.”  I tend to think that there is a promise of some sort of spiritual protection for the believer during the great tribulation. 

The Great Tribulation will be a very difficult time for believers, because of severe persecution and the degree of evil deception going on.  Revelation 13 speaks of the persecution of that time by the one called the “beast”:  “7  It was granted to him to make war with the saints and to overcome them. And authority was given him over every tribe, tongue, and nation.  8  All who dwell on the earth will worship him, whose names have not been written in the Book of Life of the Lamb slain from the foundation of the world.  9  If anyone has an ear, let him hear.  10  He who leads into captivity shall go into captivity; he who kills with the sword must be killed with the sword. Here is the  patience  and the faith of the saints.”   Notice the reference to “the patience and faith of the saints.”

 

The temptation and deception of that time will be very great, and the choices people make will be of eternal consequence (it’s the “hour of trial”), as Revelation 14 says: “If anyone worships the beast and his image, and receives [his] mark on his forehead or on his hand,  10  "he himself shall also drink of the wine of the wrath of God, which is poured out full strength into the cup of His indignation. He shall be tormented with fire and brimstone in the presence of the holy angels and in the presence of the Lamb.  11  "And the smoke of their torment ascends forever and ever; and they have no rest day or night, who worship the beast and his image, and whoever receives the mark of his name."  12  Here is the  patience  of the saints; here [are] those who keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.”   Notice again the reference to the patience of the saints-those who have “the faith of Jesus.”

 

The following may more specifically apply to the time of the early Church, but it has application to the end times as well, because there are similarities between the persecution of the early church and the time of the end:  “16  "You will be betrayed even by parents and brothers, relatives and friends; and they will put [some] of you to death.  17  "And you will be hated by all for My name's sake.  18  "But  not   a   hair  of your head shall be lost.  19  "By your patience possess your souls.” (Luke 21)   Notice the possessing of your souls by patience—this patience is a trust in God, no matter how bad it gets.  And the proverbial saying about not losing a hair of your head is not speaking about physical loss, but it’s a figure of speech, that God has possession of you, and you need to trust and obey him.  God will give you the ability to stand during that evil time.  Jesus appears to be referencing the words of the book of Micah:  7:“6  For son dishonors father,  Daughter rises against her  mother ,  Daughter- in - law  against her  mother - in - law ;  A man's enemies [are] the men of his own household.  7  Therefore I will look to the Lord;  I will wait for the God of my salvation;  My God will hear me.”

 

So I tend to see the promise in Revelation 3:10 as that of a kind of spiritual keeping from during the great tribulation.  It’s not a promise of physical removal, but a kind of deliverance from the evil of that time.   I think there can be still some difficulties with this view when it comes to the unfaithful believer and the mark of the beast.  I don’t think there is a guarantee that a believer won’t fail, so I’m not sure about that situation.  Removing the conditional statement from verse 10 and applying it to verse 9 doesn’t fully solve the problem, because the promise to the Philadelphia Church as a representative church of the end times would indicate it is for those of a certain character, not the whole church automatically.  However all this works out, it still seems the promise is not about the rapture but a spiritual kind of keeping from/ deliverance during great tribulation. 


If the keeping from is from the "Day of the Lord" according to the "prewrath" view, then it would be a keeping from the trumpets and bowls.  This then would support the view it is the rapture, because the prewrath view has the rapture before thoses things.  It could be said that the Church of Philadephia was kept from the trumpets and bowls because it is in heaven now, but so are all the other churches who didn't get this specific promise.

From a more post-trib view, the rapture would not be required, even if the "hour of trial" is specifically the trumpet and bowls, since the believer would still be on earth during those things, if those things are the more specific "test" to come upon the world.  probably a more common view of post-trib is that the second half of the 70th Week is both great tribulation and the trumpets and bowls (which I would still place near the end of the Week).

Of course there is some variations about the trumpets and bowls as to where they appear in the 70th Week.  I think it is common to place the bowls in the extra days (found at the end of Daniel chapter 12) after the 70th Week in the Prewrath view.   There may be some who have a view that places the rapture after the trumpets but before the bowls--this may be a hybrid prewrath, post-trib view.  I don't know if any prewrathers place the bowls within the 70th Week.

Actually, I'm more post-trib in my views, so even if the "hour" is the trumpets and bowls,  I can see this keeping from as referring to them, even in a physical sense, because there will be protection for those who don't have the mark of the beast.  In a post-trib rapture view, the Day of the Lord is mainly the second coming of Christ and not the trumpet and bowls.

Another concern is the words of Christ as in Luke 21 about being watchful concerning the "day" that is coming, so as to be "worthy" to "escape" what is to come and to "stand" before the Lord:  "34 "But take heed to yourselves, lest your hearts be weighed down with carousing, drunkenness, and cares of this life, and that Day come on you unexpectedly. 35 For it will come as a snare on all those who dwell on the face of the whole earth. 36 Watch therefore, and pray always that you may be counted worthy to escape all these things that will come to pass, and to stand before the Son of Man." Luke 21:34-36

This text looks like it could be about the same thing in Revelation 3.10.  The "snare" on the "whole earth" sounds close to "the hour of trial which shall come upon the whole world, to test those who dwell on the earth."   

The requirement to be worthy is troublesome, since if the rapture is in view, then it would seem one must qualify for it, unless the conduct and watchfulness is just used to identify believers by what should be characteristic of them.  What about believers who are not being watchful, and living as they should?  In First Thessalonians 5, the Apostle Paul does talk about how the Day of the Lord will come like a "thief" and the believer should not be asleep but awake, but even if he is asleep: "that whether we wake or sleep, we should live together with Him."  But Paul's words seem to connect with Luke 21 with reference to the unexpectedness of events and the need for the believer to be watchful.

Could a believer be unwatchful leading up to the trumpets and bowls, or is it more likely he is unwatchful leading up to the great tribulation?   

What is the "escape" the worthy believer is to experience?  Is it physical removal, as in the rapture?  Or is it some spiritual kind of deliverance in which they are kept from the evil?  And what exactly would that be?  He doesn't succumb but perseveres.?  Luke 21 does speak of  "stand before the son of man."  Could it be how one is spiritually going into the "trial" and "snare" will determine how they will persevere successfully and be able to stand before the Lord in approval?   Could it be the Philadelphian Church  was the kind of church that could persevere through the trial and snare that the great tribulation would bring?  And this is applicable to believers who may actually enter great tribulation?

But if the Day of the Lord is particularly in view, and from a prewrath understanding, then it would seem the rapture is what is in view.  But then there are prewrathers who believe the great tribulation is in view, and so a kind of protection would be in view.

Revelation 3.10 and Luke 21.34-36 will remain to be difficult to fully sort out.  And one will argue it according to their understanding of the rapture, whether pretrib, post-trib, or prewrath, and what the "hour of trial" is.

Tuesday, September 29, 2020

Saving faith content

Among those who believe that one is saved by faith alone ("free grace" folks), there is a difference of viewpoint as to what the content of saving faith (cosf).

There are some differences about the nature of faith and how it relates to the will.    But putting that aside for now…the cosf is an issue that has created division and hostility between those who use to work together and were friends.

Whatever view one takes on the cosf, it is agreed among free grace folks that salvation is not a result of one’s own righteousness, but that righteousness (called “justification”) by which we are saved is conferred (or imputed or reckoned) when one believes that cosf. 

Free grace folks would not equate the faith by which we are saved with the works that the Apostle Paul said that do not save us.  Faith in Christ for salvation is to be distinguished from the works of the Law or righteousness (which we have done).

 

Free grace folks would agree that salvation is received through faith in Christ. Yet they would associate more content to that faith in Christ.  Now I know some would say there are prerequisites that one must believe, about God and man, but the cosf  is really the issue. 

Whatever one is believing when salvation takes place, is what one has to believe when salvation takes place-it would seem.   It may seem that one would need to believe other things to get to that point, but that really is another issue.  Because a person could believe a lot of right and true things and not be saved.  Whatever a person believes when salvation takes place is what he has to believe for salvation to take place.   But what is that?

What is the content that is to be believed when salvation takes place?  And does that content communicate with certainty to the believer that salvation has taken place?  I ask this because one would think that if the content does not include assurance of salvation, what and why are they believing, if there is no outcome revealed in the content? Why would one believe in something unless it calls for belief and promises an outcome worth believing in?

For example, if I said that Jesus died for your sins and said nothing else, I haven’t communicated to him what the outcome is.   If I tell them that Jesus died for their sins, and they need to believe in him, I gave them more content, but I still haven’t communicated what the outcome of that is.   If I tell them that Jesus died for their sins, and if they believe that, they will be saved, I’ve given them content that includes an outcome that includes assurance of salvation, an outcome that requires a response of faith in not only that Jesus died for their sins, but that if they believe in Him, they will be saved.  (Now I haven’t explained what Jesus dying for sins can mean in this content, such as Jesus’ death satisfied the righteous demands against our sins by which God is able to justify and regenerate us, but if that was explained, there still would need to be communicated how God justifies and regenerates or saves since the death of Christ for sin does not automatically result in salvation to everyone.) 

Most would probably include the outcome with the content of saving faith, but what about how the outcome is received?  Some would identify the faith by which we are saved as just the response (and some may even call faith a kind of work), but it is part of the content.  Doesn’t one have to know and believe they are saved by faith?  

If you believe Christ died for all, and all are not saved, then how can one know they are saved, even if they believe Jesus died for their sins?  If his death didn’t save everyone, then how do you know it saves you?  (Some believe Christ’s death took everyone’s sins away in a judicial sins sense, while others believe the judicial remission of sins does not happen until one believes, but in either case, no one is automatically saved because Jesus died for them; salvation is still conditional.)  

How can one know they are saved?  Do they have to know they are saved by faith?    Does one have to believe they are saved by faith to be saved?  For if the death of Christ is for all, and not all are saved, how do you know you are saved, even if you believe Jesus died for your sins.

It would help if there were some biblical accounts of people getting saved in response to words spoken that we could examine every detail of the message.

What about the Cornelius account?  He was to send for Peter who would “tell him words by which [he] …would be saved.” (Acts 11.14)  When we examine those words, we have content spoken that is immediately followed by Cornelius’ salvation, evident by his speaking in tongues. (Some believe Cornelius was already an Old Testament Gentile saint, since he feared God and was a godly man, and even if that is true, his salvation had to be connected with believing certain words about Jesus--maybe for his sake and a Jew like Peter to know how Gentiles are saved).

Peter said: “To Him All the prophets bear witness that, through His name, whoever believes in Him will receive remission of sins.” (Acts 10.43)  Prior to this, Peter makes references to Jesus being proclaimed throughout Judea, and Cornelius knew about this.  Peter makes reference to Jesus being killed and resurrected and the judge of the living and dead.  He then says that whoever believes in Him will receive remission of sins. 

Peter doesn’t really explain the value of Christ’s death, he only says that by believing in him, one receives remission of sins, which I understand to be the same as being saved from sin.  But we see here the need for faith in Christ ("whoever believes in Him")—which everyone in the content debate should agree on, and the response of faith that brings an outcome of remission of sins.   I think we need to see all this as the content:  salvation (11.14) is a result in believing in Jesus for remission of sins, and this was the witness of the prophets.  The means and the outcome are both there.  I think a proper understand of Jesus' divine authority has to be included, though it isn't really brought out.  But Cornelius could have had a similar understanding as the Samaritans who anticipated the Messiah who would be the Savior of the world.

How do I know I have salvation or the remission of sins?  Because the Words of Scripture says that if you believe in Him, Jesus, you will receive remission of sins.  Obviously, I am believing in Him for the remission of sins, because that is what is offered or prophesied or promised in the words.  If the purpose of the coming of Peter was to speak words by which Cornelius would be saved, and Peter spoke the words, and Cornelius believed and was saved, then we have a biblical example of the content of saving faith.   If Cornelius was already saved, then his salvation was to be connected specifically with believing in Jesus as the Jewish Messiah and son of God who would suffer for sin and give forgiveness of sins to all who believed in him for it.  That connection was for the benefit of both Cornelius and Peter--who still had to learn that gentiles could be saved just like Jews by faith alone in the Christ and Savior.

Wednesday, September 16, 2020

A Measure of Free Will

I believe we have a certain measure of free will.   I believe that measure of free will has to do with the ability to make choices, even of a spiritual nature.  The argument is over there is any ability to make any kind of choices of a spiritual nature due to one’s fallen, sinful nature.

 

Free will does not mean one can do something he was not created to do, like choose to grow wings and fly like a bird.   Some will argue that one cannot respond to God positively because of his fallen nature, and this is why will require regeneration before one can respond, while others will say it’s not regeneration, but something like it—like a “quickening” (using the King James language in Ephesians 2.5) in which one is able to believe the gospel, and then they receive regeneration.  I would seriously question that there is both a quickening and a regeneration, because the quickening is really just another term for being made alive which is the same as regeneration:  it is the impartation of eternal life.  Whether one is regenerated or “quickened,” they surely mean the same thing, but I believe Scripture is clear that regeneration happens when we believe, not before we believe. 

 

Some (or many) believe in “total depravity,” which says one is totally unable to respond to God positively.  According to this total depravity, if man has any free will, it is within the limits of his total depravity, and that depravity is such that for him to respond to God, there must be regeneration or a quickening of some sort first.  

 

There was this guy who use to ridicule the idea of free will with a fictional story.  He told the story about a boy who grew up in a home in which his father told him that chocolate ice cream was bad for him, that it was poison, and if he ate it, he would die.  This was constantly taught to the child.  So, when the father and son went to get ice cream, and the offer was made to him of either vanilla or chocolate, he would obviously choose vanilla.  He could not by his free will choose chocolate because of his conditioning.  But this story leaves out the fact that one could be persuaded contrary to what he was always taught and accepted as true.  Choices are not always made in such an environment as this story, but even in such an environment, what difference could it have made if a reliable source and demonstration showed that the father was a liar?  What if the grandfather came along and told the boy that his father was not truthful, that he loved chocolate and always tried to keep it all to himself.  The grandfather said Chocolate ice cream is not poisonous, and to demonstrate it, he ate some in his presence.  The boy could know that his father lied, and so could actually then choose to have it.  This is the part the guy would leave out: the power of persuasion by demonstration to change one’s mind.  This is where free will actually does work, because through demonstration and persuasion, one can choose differently, even against previous beliefs and feelings. It is how I understand repentance as the resolve to think or do differently due to persuasion.

 

This is why God in Romans 11.11 can be said to be seeking to provoke the Jews to jealousy by salvation coming to the gentiles.  (I think this salvation is probably more than justification, but the purpose of God to have a people for his name through the gentiles.)  Why would God need to do this if he just needed to “quicken” or regenerate them to believe?  God, by putting gentiles into a role of privilege and blessing as the people for his purpose, just as previously was the nation of Israel, could stir up the unbelieving Jews to what they had missed, and then some might choose to seek the truth about the person of Jesus and come to the knowledge of salvation through faith in Jesus for salvation.  

 

Free will involves the ability to choose between different options.  Sometimes, a choice that seems very unlikely can be helped along by persuasion and repentance.  People can be persuaded to make choices contrary to what they prefer or desire, because they are persuaded otherwise.  It may be that some our more stubborn than others, or more fearful.  The reasons why some respond one way and others another is complex.  But if we are talking about salvation, why is it any different than anything else people agree and disagree on?  Why is it we make responding to the way of eternal life different than the way people respond to anything else?  I think because of certain theology that is so engrained in the thinking of so many.  Some are willing to be persuaded otherwise.  It’s probably often the case that one won’t be persuaded about anything unless they are willing to consider other arguments and have questions. 

 

By a “measure of free will,” I believe we have the capacity to make choices and to have a change of mind, if we are willing to consider different viewpoints and evidence that may be contrary to what we have believed before.  

Sunday, September 13, 2020

Socialization and homeschool

When my wife and I decided to homeschool our children, and one of the concerns I heard was "what about their socialization?

Socialization (definition):
noun 1. the activity of mixing socially with others.
"Socialization with students has helped her communication skills."
2. the process of learning to behave in a way that is acceptable to society.
"Preschool starts the process of socialization."

We were not so concerned about this.  

My main concern was over the content of the teaching and the philosophy that the school material and the individual teachers would try to promote.


Children should learn their social skills primarily from their parents and maybe grandparents.  If parents do not provide a good example and try to instill proper behavior around others, I think it will be more difficult for their children to have good social skills.

Children can still have contact with other children through siblings, other relatives, neighbors and friends.  They also can have interaction with children at church.

Other children can often have a bad influence on your children.  There is usually pressure from other children to do things you know you shouldn't.

Kids in school are a varied bunch of immature characters.  I made some friends in school, but we didn't always get along.  Kids can be mean and form their little cliques.    Few kids are able to stand alone when the group is doing something they shouldn't, and I think this is a real concern for parents who want to instill certain values in their children, for they are under the pressure to adopt the behavior of the group of kids they are socializing with.  That pressure often involves some alcohol drinking, drug use, premarital sex or pornography, vandalism, and just rebellious behavior.  The socialization of the public school makes this easier to participate in, because so many are doing it.  I saw it all going on back in the mid 70's, so the need for socialization by the public school doesn't interest me. 

The majority of children in school have little or no exposure to the Bible, and that includes teachers, so don't be surprised if your children become even more alienated to spiritual things.  The public school is not a place for Christian education, but it makes it more difficult when the teaching has a subtle philosophy that is antichristian.