Sunday, September 19, 2021

The Martyrs of Revelation 20:4 and the timing of the Rapture

In Revelation 20:4, we see those who were martyred for their faith during the time of the "beast" and the implementation of his "image."  The text says that they "lived and reigned with Christ for a thousand years."  This quote is from the New King James, but translations like the ESV say that they "came to life and reigned..."  This translation is why some would argue that their resurrection was at this point in time; and this is an argument against a PreWrath or Post-Trib rapture, because why were they resurrected at this point in time and not with those resurrected at the end of the Great Tribulation in a PreWrath or Post-Trib rapture scenario?

The text identifies them as "souls," and I see no reason not to see them as those identified earlier in the 5th seal of Revelation 6.9-11.  Those souls in the fifth seal were martyred for their faith, and there were more to come, and I can't see why they are not the same as the souls of Revelation 20.4.  

The word "souls" in Revelation 20.4 surely reminds the reader of those previously mentioned in the fifth seal.  At this point in the vision, which John is receiving, special attention and recognition are given to these souls.  I think that the designation "souls" doesn't have to mean disembodied spirits that still need to be resurrected, but particular people who are seen and remembered and now comforted about their future.  It's not that they were resurrected as a distinct group apart from others, but they are given special attention at this point in the vision, and their status is revealed.

Translations make it sound like they are resurrected at the time of Revelation 20.4, which would be an argument against a Prewrath or Post-Trib rapture view, because if the rapture was Post-trib, why weren't they resurrected with the dead believers at the end of the Great Tribulation?  I believe they were resurrected then, but they receive particular attention and recognition at that point in the vision.   

The word translated "lived" in the NKJ is the same as the word "reigned" in tense, being indicative/ aorist / active, and they both speak of their fate, being they "lived and reigned with Christ for a thousand years."  This is in contrast to the unsaved who do not live again until after the thousand years: "But the rest of the dead did not live again until the thousand years were finished." 20:5 NKJ  The verb "live" in verse 5 is also the same Greek tense.   The Martyrs will both live and reign with Christ for a thousand years, while the unsaved will not even live during the thousand years.  

Revelation 20.5 also says that "This is the first resurrection."   The first resurrection would be the one preceding the Rapture.  The Martyrs were part of that Resurrection, and they will both live and reign with Christ.  The unsaved will be resurrected later, and they will not live until after the Thousand years.

I think that a Post-trib view has a little advantage over the PreWrath view in this, because the Prewrath view has an undetermined amount of time between the end of the Great Tribulation, when the resurrection and rapture happens, and the end of the 70th Week or the Bowls' judgments, which they usually put beyond the 70th Week. For what of any new believers who possibly die as Martyrs, as these need to be accounted for?  But I'm not sure if PreWrathers are seeing the Martyrs of Revelation 20:4 as a very specific group between the Rapture at the end of Great Tribulation and the final defeat of the Beast by Christ.   I think the Martyrs of Revelation 20:4 are the same as the fifth seal Martyrs.  

It makes sense to me that the "souls" of Revelation 20:4 are the fifth seal Martyrs who are resurrected at the end of the Great Tribulation, and those particular individuals get special attention and recognition: they will both live and reign with Christ for a thousand years.

4 And I saw thrones, and they sat on them, and judgment was committed to them. Then I saw the souls of those who had been beheaded for their witness to Jesus and for the word of God, who had not worshiped the beast or his image, and had not received his mark on their foreheads or on their hands. And they lived and reigned with Christ for a thousand years. 5 But the rest of the dead did not live again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection. 6 Blessed and holy is he who has part in the first resurrection. Over such the second death has no power, but they shall be priests of God and of Christ, and shall reign with Him a thousand years. Revelation 20:4-6


Parable of the Sower: varied outcomes to the saving message

Matthew 13:3-9; 18-23; Mark 4:1–9; 13-20; Luke 8:4–8; 11-15

Jesus called it the parable of the Sower, though it seems it is about the soils and their conditions.  It must be that it is simply a message about how the Sower should be prepared for different results.  The parable is not designed to answer every question one can throw at it.  It doesn't explain why or how the soils are different.  We see that the seed spread has different outcomes based on the precondition of the soil.  We don't get any information as to whether the soil is stuck in the condition forever.  We only see the outcomes from the sowing of the seed in different soils and the outward affect by certain forces on the growth (or non-growth) of the seed in such soils.

In the explanation of the parable, looking at parallel texts, we see that the seed is the word of God and the word of the kingdom.  In the First Case-example, the word is not understood, and Satan takes the word out of the recipient's heart, so they may not believe and be saved.  This reveals that the word here is a saving message.  The Word of the Kingdom to be a saving-content message must be concerning Jesus as the Christ who is Savior from sin for those who believe in Him for it; for to believe this is to be born again and qualify to see and enter the Kingdom of God—according to John 3 and what we read about the Samaritans in John 4 who believed that Jesus was the Christ, the Savior of the World.  If one doesn't understand the message, as far as the terms of salvation, then Satan works in a way to keep one from understanding it and believing it.

The next 2 Cases are debated as to the outcome of the recipients as to whether they are actually saved. It seems common for Free Grace folks to believe they are saved (see quote one below), while non-Free Grace do not, though there may be exceptions (see quote two below).  The latter expects a perseverance of the saints view in salvation, while the former would say that Salvation does not guarantee perseverance.   The outcome in Cases Two and Three are that the results are short-lived due to the condition of the soil and the outward conditions on the plant.  We can't answer questions with this parable that the parable wasn't meant to answer or doesn't answer.  Persecution and the cares of life will bring failure if one is not rooted and grounded in the truth.   That is the outcome in these cases.   Is the failure due to these not really understanding and therefore not believing? It is tempting to make arguments from silence, since we are not told whether they understood and believed or didn't understand and disbelieve.  It seems they did understand and believe, but their sanctification-progress was later interrupted by worldly cares and persecution.  It seems they are both those who do not "endure to the end" (Mat 10:22, 24:13:  they are those who did not "lose their souls for Christ's sake and the gospel"—as Jesus said, (Mark 8.35)..."whoever desires to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for My sake will find it." (Mat 16.25)   The truth is that Jesus did not say whether they understood and believed or didn’t understand and disbelieved.  One’s view will be based on their soteriology, whether saving faith will persevere or quickly recover or eventually recover (in some reasonable amount of time) after failure under the circumstances that cause the failure.  

The Fourth Case hears the word and understands and bears fruit, but not equally among those who receive it.  We don't know why that is, as far as the explanation, but the good soil has varied outcomes itself.  We don't know why these have good soil and the others don't  We are not told about those who have good soil and bear fruit for a time, then become less fruitful or unfruitful.  Again, the parable doesn’t answer things like that.  Some suggest good soil is regeneration, and that is why they understand and bear fruit, and that will be your conclusion if you are of the Reformed Theology mindset. (Moderate Calvinists might say it is a "quickening," but that is a word used in Scripture for either the resurrection of the body or the new birth, and so it's an attempt to come up with something like regeneration to enable the unsaved to be saved by faith before regeneration.)

Jesus doesn't explain how the soils were prepared.  In farming, we use to prepare soil for planting, by disking, plowing, and dragging—sometimes twice. What creates good soil?  Who's responsible for good soil.  Why varied amounts of fruit?  The parable doesn't answer those questions.  It only illustrates varied outcomes  to the word of God spoken based on human heart-psychological conditions.   

Quote One:  While many commentators say the second soil represents another type of unbeliever, that view is untenable because the seed sprang up (v 5), and clearly germination must precede springing up! Luke 8:13 specifically says that this person believed the saving message for a time. Sadly, apostasy is possible for born-again people. Of course, everlasting life, once it has germinated, is everlasting--even if the faith later fails. Then there are the distracted hearers. Their hearts' interest is deflected away from God toward seductive material and worldly pursuits (Matt 13:22). “The cares of this world" refer to the worries or excessive concerns of this life. “The deceitfulness of riches" refers to the false security offered by the accumulation of temporal wealth (cf. Luke 12: 15-21). Riches may promise fulfillment, but they fail to deliver. The result of the worldly distractions is that the person "becomes unfruitful." The believer represented by this soil perseveres in faith, but his works are not brought to maturity (cf. Luke 8:14).  Quoted from The Grace New Testament Commentary, Matthew, Hal Haller Jr.

Quote Two: D. A. Carson seems to believe Case Two is an unsaved person, for he says the person receives the word "in a thoughtless way" that "may show immediate signs of life and promise to be the best of the crop...But without real root, there is no fruit; and external pressures, trouble, and persecution..., like the sun beating on a rootless plant, soon reveals the shallowness of the soil. ... Such temporary disciples are always numerous in times of revival and were so in Jesus' ministry."

In Case Three, Carson doesn't say he is a nonbeliever, so it's unclear whether in this case he believes unfruitfulness is a lack of spiritual life in a believer or lack of spiritual life in the sense of a lack of eternal life.  Carson says of this person that he "simply never permits the message about the kingdom to control him:  life has too many other commitments that slowly choke the struggling plant, which never matures and bears fruit."  Carson says about the "deceitfulness" or "delightfulness" "of wealth"..."The idea is clear: worries about worldly things or devotion to wealth...snuff out spiritual life...If deceit is understood...these thorns are so subtle that one may not be aware of the choking that is going on...What must be avoided is unfruitfulness, for only fruitfulness, not it's opposite, indicates spiritual life..."   The Expositor's Bible Commentary, Matthew

Sunday, August 29, 2021

Is Jerusalem's destruction in Luke 21:20-24 that of Babylon the Great?

Could Jerusalem's destruction in Luke 21.20-24 be that of the destruction of Babylon the Great [BTG] in Rev 17.16?  Would Jesus have had in mind BTG in Luke 21, instead of the coming destruction of Jerusalem that he prophesied in Luke 19.41-44? 

Those who believe Jerusalem is BTG might see Luke 21.20-24 as referring to the destruction of BTG in Rev 17, 18, and 16.19.  Some would see 2 stages of that destruction, being by the 10 horns in which it is burned, and then by God in the 7th bowl, according to Rev 16.19.   I could see how one might identify Luke 21.20-24 as BTG, since the prophesy is followed by the cosmic disturbance event and second coming (see Luke 21.25-27) that comes at the end of the Great Tribulation [GT] (see Matthew 24:29-30).  If Jesus speaks of the destruction of AD70, then there is a big gap of time between the desolation of Jerusalem and the cosmic disturbances.

But would Jesus have had that far future destruction of BTG in view since he prophesied of Jerusalem's near destruction in Luke 19:41-44?  That destruction is foretold in the words of the parable in Matthew 22 about the king's army who destroys and burns the city.  There's also the reference to the destruction of the city in Daniel 9.24-26 that fits in the near future time after Christ's first coming.    I don't think Jesus had Jerusalem as BTG in view, though if Jerusalem is BTG, I could see how it might seem to be in view.  But if Jerusalem is not BTG, it obviously can't be BTG in Luke 21.  

It is curious that a near future prophecy of AD70 is immediately followed by a prophecy of the cosmic events that follow the GT.   Rev 18.4 does exhort God's people to come out of BTG, and Luke 21.21 does warn to flee Jerusalem, but it also speaks of it as days of vengeance, but wasn't that vengeance back in AD70?   But there is a vengeance on BTG as the city that shed the blood of the prophets and apostles and saints, Rev 18.20, 24.  Luke 21 also speaks of Jerusalem being trampled by gentiles; this could be AD70 and onward, but it could be referring to the great tribulation period (see Revelation 11:1-3) , and maybe this destruction is at that time, being burned by fire.  

The prophecy of Jerusalem in Luke 21 would seem to fit with the destruction of BTG, and the close connection of the cosmic disturbances would support that, though it could be that the connection is that Jerusalem will be trampled by Gentiles from AD70 onward until the time of the cosmic disturbances at the end of the Great Tribulation.  Luke 21 says Jerusalem will be trampled until the "times of the gentiles are fulfilled."  That "times of the gentiles" has been identified as the whole time Jerusalem is under the overlordship of gentiles.  Yet Ezekiel speaks of the "Day of the Lord" as the "time of the gentiles," 30:3.  It could be understood that from AD70 onward, Jerusalem will be trampled underfoot by gentiles until the Day of the Lord is fulfilled, which comes in connection with the cosmic disturbances.  This makes the connection with such a long gap between the AD70 destruction of Jerusalem and the cosmic events.  The Day of the Lord will be the time of the gentiles' distress.

So, would Jesus have had in mind the destruction of BTG in light of his prophecy about Jerusalem being destroyed in Luke 19?   Near and far prophecies being together is not all that unusual.   Jerusalem being BTG in Luke 21 would probably work if there are 2 stages of BTG's destruction, as some believe; the first stage near the beginning of GT--though it seems the armies of the world are gathered against Jerusalem near the end of the 70th Week (Zechariah 12.3)--yet Zechariah indicates God will protect the city, 12.9.   

There are similarities between Luke 21 and the fate of BTG, but there are uncertainties too.   Maybe the similarities are intended, making the ability to sort it out difficult until we are very near that time.

Sunday, August 22, 2021

To inherit and to enter the kingdom of God

Jesus said one must be born again to enter the kingdom of God, John 3.3-5.  Jesus said to the sheep, "Come, you blessed of My Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world," Matthew 25:34  

The words "enter" and "inherit" do not mean the same thing, but they seem to speak to the same thing in these two references: those who inherit the kingdom will enter the kingdom.  

Does "inherit" always simply refer to those who will enter the kingdom, or does it speak of reward in some usages?     All believers are heirs, if entrance is understood as inheritance.  But could there be heirs of a more restricted kind based on performance in this life?

When Paul gives a vice list, he speaks of those who will not inherit the kingdom, being those who commit immorality.  I believe he is speaking of unsaved people who are identified by what is often characteristic of them, and he is telling believers not to do such things: "9 Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived. Neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor homosexuals, nor sodomites, 10 nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners will inherit the kingdom of God." 1 Corinthians 6:9-10  Since believers can do these things, I think some will say that this inheritance is about rewards, but I think that here, Paul is speaking of the unsaved by what characterizes them, and we who are saved should not do these things.  The unsaved, the unrighteous, will not inherit the kingdom, and we who are saved, the righteous, should not do these things, because these things belong to our old man/ self-identity and are unbecoming of a child of God.  

But Scripture does seem to make a distinction about inheritance that seems to go beyond entrance into the kingdom to co-ruling with Christ: "... if children, then heirs—heirs of God and joint heirs with Christ, if indeed we suffer with Him, that we may also be glorified together."  Romans 8:17   This may be the case where not all inheritance will be equal, unless all believers in some sense suffer with Christ.  All believers are children and therefore heirs, which means they will inherit the kingdom.  But it may be that the inheritance is not equal as far as status or recognition in the kingdom, based on faithfulness in this life.  There are Scriptures that indicate reward or recognition in the life to come.  Inheritance among children is not always equal, and performance can be a basis for different distributions of inheritance.  His lord said to him, 'Well done, good and faithful servant; you have been faithful over a few things, I will make you ruler over many things. Enter into the joy of your lord.' Matthew 25:23   This is a parable, however, and it is at least making the point that one is accountable for what God has dispensed, and there is divine recognition and some sort of reward for being faithful with what God has dispensed.

Friday, August 13, 2021

Quickened?

Some believe that God “quickens” a person so that they can believe and be saved.  

This word “quicken” is an old English translation of the Greek “Zoopoieo” more commonly translated “make alive” as in Ephesians 2:5.  The idea of a quickening for faith is according to the theology of “total depravity” in which one is too depraved to believe and be saved, and it is a substitution for the Reformed view that that regeneration comes before faith--a view that some Calvinists find problematic.  

I believe the Greek words zoopoieo and syzoopoieo, translated “make alive” or “give life to” either speak of the resurrection or regeneration. 

It seems to be just a theological requirement to make the Greek words refer to some act of God before faith, but the usages are actually about the resurrection or regeneration.   God does make alive again the believer through regeneration and in the resurrection.  There is no requirement to come up with something like regeneration before saving faith and call it a quickening.  The quickening is regeneration or resurrection, and both happen after saving faith--the latter after physical death at the second coming.

God quickens by regeneration those who believe.  “Total depravity” is a Calvinist theology that requires a pre-faith enablement. 

Depravity is a sufficient term to speak of mankind’s condition, and why the new birth is necessary, but a pre-faith enablement is not necessary.  The work of Holy Spirit through Scripture is sufficient.

References where the Greek words appear are Rom 8.11; 1 Cor 15.22, 36; Eph 2.5; Col 2.13; 1 Pet 3.18.  Also found in the LXX.

Sunday, August 8, 2021

The Successive-Final View of the Seals, Trumpets, and Bowls of Revelation.

I tend towards a Post-Tribulation Rapture view that sees the seals, trumpets, and bowls of Revelation as successive, and yet with overlap at the end of each group, the "successive-final view" as seen in the picture below.  


This means the three groups of events are mostly successive, that is, sequential in that each group transpires before the next according to the order given, except for the final event of each group, each of which parallel one-another.  For the seals, both number 6 and 7 line up with the final event--number 7--of the trumpets and bowls.   In this view, the great tribulation continues to the end of the 70th Week that concludes with the 6th and 7th seal, the 7th trumpet and bowl, followed by the Coming (parousia) of Christ and the Day of the Lord.  The Day of the Lord is the direct wrath of Christ at his coming upon the nations beginning with the battle of Armageddon...

12 Then the sixth angel poured out his bowl on the great river Euphrates, and its water was dried up, so that the way of the kings from the east might be prepared. 13 And I saw three unclean spirits like frogs coming out of the mouth of the dragon, out of the mouth of the beast, and out of the mouth of the false prophet. 14 For they are spirits of demons, performing signs, which go out to the kings of the earth and of the whole world, to gather them to the battle of that great day of God Almighty.

15 “Behold, I am coming as a thief. Blessed is he who watches, and keeps his garments, lest he walk naked and they see his shame.”
16 And they gathered them together to the place called in Hebrew, Armageddon. Revelation 16:12-16

This is a brief post, but I've written more elsewhere on why I'm Post-Trib and how I understand the "Day of the Lord."  This is just a statement of how I understand the progression of the seals, trumpets, and bowls in relationship to one-another.





Tuesday, June 29, 2021

The burdens and yoke of the local Church

Jesus said, "For My yoke is easy and My burden is light." Matthew 11:30 This probably speaks of discipleship, which should come after one believes in him for salvation--which I believe he invited to earlier: "Come to Me, all you who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest." Matthew 11:28. It's the ambitions of man that places an unnecessary burden on others to build that organization manifested in the local church.


The local church puts burdens on people that I think encourage people to stay away. The expectations, traditions and programs, can be an unnecessary burden. They require commitment to be maintained. But are they necessary? Those who don't attend regularly or don't help in the maintenance of these things may still expect them when they attend, so someone must maintain them. But do they really need to?


The church is the people. Bigger buildings and programs will have their attraction, but the burden to maintain them is usually put on a few. People may not come if you don't have the facilities and programs, but they won't come if you put the maintenance of the operation on them as well.


The purpose of the gathering is to build one another up and to stir one another up: Hebrews 10:26; Ephesians 4:11-16. If people don't want to come for this purpose, then why try to draw them in with those things that a few are burdened to maintain?


Jesus' yoke and burden are easy and light through the enabling that comes through abiding in the word of God and through a simplicity of believers assembling together to edify one another through the roles they have. But it doesn't seem to work quite this way, because of the expectation and traditions of the maintenance of property, programs, and the vocational staff. I don't think this will change, and so the burdens will continue, because of the usual expectations and traditions.